SAA Statement: NARA Exhibit on 2017 Women's March in Washington, DC

January 19, 2020—A January 17 article in the Washington Post, “National Archives exhibit blurs images critical of President Trump,” raises serious concerns for the Society of American Archivists about falsification of the historical record, politicization of the National Archives and its public exhibitions, and professional obligations for objectivity and honesty.

Archivists are professionals who are bound by a Code of Ethics that includes the following statement about authenticity: “Archivists ensure the authenticity and continuing usability of records in their care. They document and protect the unique archival characteristics of records and strive to protect the records’ intellectual and physical integrity from tampering or corruption. Archivists may not willfully alter, manipulate, or destroy data or records to conceal facts or distort evidence. They thoroughly document any actions that may cause changes to the records in their care or raise questions about the records’ authenticity.”

The doctored photograph is an enlarged image of a massive demonstration in support of women’s rights—the Women’s March on January 21, 2017, in Washington, DC. Staff of the National Archives deliberately blurred or altered at least four of the protest signs shown in the photograph. Not only does this violate the archivist's responsibility to be objective (and to follow professional values and best practices), but this alteration is fraudulent and deceptive. It purports to prevent young people from seeing "disturbing" words and to avoid partisan statements. But this is the entire purpose of public demonstrations.

At a time when the honesty and integrity of government agencies and public officials has been called into question by many Americans, the National Archives must set an example of accurate representation of the nation’s history.

In a January 18 statement, the National Archives apologized for its action:

“We made a mistake.

“As the National Archives of the United States, we are and have always been completely committed to preserving our archival holdings, without alteration.

“In a promotional display in this spot, we obscured some words on protest signs in a photo of the 2017 Women’s March. This photo is not an archival record held by the National Archives, but one we licensed to use as a promotional graphic.
“Nonetheless, we were wrong to alter the image.

“We have removed the display and will replace it as soon as possible with one that uses the unaltered image.

“We apologize, and will immediately start a thorough review of our exhibit policies and procedures so that this does not happen again.”

SAA encourages completion of the policy and procedure review as soon as possible as a signal of NARA’s ongoing commitment to defending accuracy and respect for historical documentation.

Approved by the SAA Executive Committee, January 19, 2020.

Comments

98029 says:

Archivists may not willfully alter, manipulate, or destroy data or records to conceal facts or distort evidence. 

drywall contractor

102728 says:

Unlock the potential of your business with our expert SEO services. Drive traffic, boost rankings, and dominate search engine results today!

In reply to by 98029

Elan Real says:

At Elan Real Estate, every property tells a story. Whether you’re buying your first home or your fifth, we ensure your narrative begins in the right place with elite real estate in Dubai. https://elanrealestate.ae/

In reply to by 102728

98409 says:

It's important to acknowledge the significance of the Women's March and the impact it had on the United States and the world. The Women's March was a historic event that saw millions of people come together to advocate for women's rights and other social justice issues. It's crucial that we preserve the historical records and artifacts of such events for future generations. See: https://www.stpaulguttercleaner.com/gutter-installation-in-stpaul-mn

Coby says:

The Society of American Archivists expresses deep concern regarding the potential distortion of historical accuracy in the National Archives' recent exhibit, as reported in the Washington Post on January 17. Archivists uphold a Code of Ethics that prioritizes the authenticity and preservation of records. Any alterations to records that conceal facts or compromise their integrity go against our professional principles. In this light, it is essential to maintain objectivity and honesty in presenting historical information. For more insightful discussions on history and authenticity, visit Watcher of Realms - Ignite Your Heroic Journey Today! and continue to Games.lol blog.

97981 says:

Archivists ensure the authenticity and continuing usability of records in their care. They document and protect the unique archival characteristics of records and strive to protect the records’ intellectual and physical integrity from tampering or corruption. 

 

DFW Bath & Kitchen Solution bathroom flooring dallas

 

Ara says:

In a time when the integrity of government agencies and public officials is under scrutiny, it is imperative that institutions like the National Archives demonstrate a commitment to transparency, honesty, and accuracy in preserving the nation's history. Miami Beach Realtors

107640 says:

Looking for stylish and elegant clothing? Click Here to explore Apricocia’s latest collection and find the perfect outfit that suits your style!

107640 says:

Craving delicious Chinese food? Explore the full Panda Express menu for a variety of tasty options that will satisfy every craving. Click Here to discover all the flavors waiting for you!

107640 says:

Looking for reliable hosting services? Read More about the top-notch solutions offered by to elevate your website’s performance and reliability.

108343 says:

The Society of American Archivists (SAA) strongly criticized the National Archives for altering a photograph of the 2017 Women’s March, calling it a violation of archival ethics and historical integrity. The National Archives admitted the mistake, apologized, and pledged to review its policies to prevent future alterations. Maintaining accuracy in historical documentation is crucial, as seen in cases like this where public trust is at stake. According to Wikipedia, the 2017 Women’s March was a global protest advocating for women's rights and social justice. For those planning visits during the holidays, cava-holiday-hours can help ensure a smooth experience.

kovronski says:

The 2017 Women's March was such a powerful moment in history, and it's great to see it being documented in exhibits like the one at NARA. While exploring ways to represent such meaningful moments, I thought about the importance of personal items like jewelry that often hold deep meaning. Giliarto alexandrite rings offers some stunning Alexandrite rings, which are not only beautiful but can serve as symbolic pieces that mark significant moments in one’s life, much like the march. If you’re interested in adding a symbolic piece of jewelry to commemorate important events, their collection could be a perfect fit.